10 Best Round Cake Pans 2020 – Expert Reviews & Guide

There are more than a billion people in this world today; each of them has different hobbies and passions. Among these passions and hobbies, baking might be one of the common ones. I know a dozen people who love to spend their free time baking and trying something new.

Who does not love a tasty cake? I love it; my kids love it. It is one of the most delicious things that could be made at home. Baking a cake might seem a stressful process to some people, but once you master the skill of mixing the dough, then you will start enjoying it. As important as the mixing of the dough, the baking pan is also important.

Not all cake bake pans come made in the same way; some of them could be made of a particular metal and some made of a combination of materials. Each type of material will have its own advantages and disadvantages. It is totally up to the user on which product to purchase. However, today the demand for cake bake pans are comparatively very higher than the previous years and it is one of the main reasons why selecting the best product and purchasing it is not an easy task, but to make things easier for you, we have selected some products from the market and these products will definitely satisfy your requirements.

Best Buy Round Cake Pan Reviews

Here is the list of 10 best round cake pans available in 2020:-

1. Wilton Performance Aluminum Pan

Wilton Performance Aluminum Pan

Buy From Amazon

No one who spends some quality time mixing the dough in the right proportion would prefer ending up using a worthless cake pan. If you are a person who needs the best cake pan from the market today, then this product is the best option for you.

This cake pan, unlike most of the products listed below, comes in different size variants to be precise 14 different size variants. However, we would recommend that you go for 8×2-inch cake pan as it is one of the best for baking. This cake pan is designed for baking layered cakes, and the entire product comes made of high-quality aluminum. The pan is 2-inches deep and is designed to spread heat evenly all over the surface. One of the notable things about this cake bake pan is that the interior of the pan is smooth like in nonstick coating, this makes cake release after baking easy.

Things we liked

  • Reasonable price
  • Made of thick aluminum
  • Even heat distribution factor
  • 2-inches deep
  • Best for layered cakes

Things we did not like

  • Not dishwasher safe

2. Fat Daddio’s Round Cake Pan

Fat Daddio Cake Pan

Buy From Amazon

Are you looking for the best round cake pan available on the market today? Then we recommend that you should consider purchasing this cake bake pan.

Unlike most of the cake bake pan available on the market today, this product comes in a pack of two. Based on the manufacturer and customer, this product comes in a size of 6-inches diameter and a height of 2-inches. One of the notable things about this product is that it comes designed in such a way that it can be used in air fryers. The entire product comes made of high-quality anodized aluminum, the adonization process makes the aluminum non-reactive and makes it best for baking and cooking food with citrus-basedrecipes. Yet another thing about this product is that the product is designed in such a way that it can heat and cool easily

Things we liked

  • Designed to heat and cool quickly
  • Anodized-aluminum made bake pan
  • Does not have any chemical coating
  • Has a durable non-reactive finish
  • Can be used for multiple purposes
  • Lifetime warranty

Things we did not like

  • Cannot be washed in a dishwasher

3. GreenLife Ceramic Round Cake Pan

GreenLife Ceramic Round Cake Pan

Buy From Amazon

Some people like purchasing and using premium cake bake pans, and if you are such a person then, this product is the best option for you.

This cake pan comes from the top brand GreenLife, and it is one of the best cake pans available on the market today. This cake bake pan comes with high-quality ceramic coating that does not have any chemicals or any other harmful substances. The entire product comes made of heavy-duty steel that ensures fast and even heat distribution. The manufacturer claims that the cake pan can handle a heat up to 450-degree Fahrenheit. One of the notable things about this product is that the nonstick coating on it is smooth and it allows the easy release of cake after baking, the nonstick coating also makes cleaning easy as it does not allow any residue to stick on it.

Things we liked

  • Made of heavy-duty steel
  • Designed or fast and even heating
  • High-quality chemical-free nonstick coating
  • No chemicals on nonstick
  • Easy to clean

Things we did not like

  • Can be washed with hands only, or the nonstick coating might come off

4. USA Pan Bakeware Round Cake Pan

USA Pan Bakeware Round Cake Pan

Buy From Amazon

USA Pan has a legacy in manufacturing and marketing top quality cake bake pans in the world today. The quality of the bake pans stands second to no other products on this list and if you need the best perfect cake bake pan, you should consider purchasing this product.

This cake bake pan comes with an overall diameter of 9-inches, and it is made of high-quality commercial and heavy-gauge aluminized steel. The manufacturer offers a lifetime warranty on the product and the material. One of the notable things about this product is that it comes with a coating on it, Americoat that enables the easy release of cake from the pan after baking. The same coating also makes it easier to clean, all you need is hot water, soap, and sponge to clean the pan. To be precise Americoat is a silicone coating on the pan which is 100% free of BPA, PTFE, and PFOA. Yet another thing about this product is that it comes made in the USA and the brand has been around for over 50-years. There is something else about this product that makes it unique; the entire interior of the pan comes with a fluted design that helps in increasing the nonstick properties and at the same time, prevents the pan from wrapping under high temperature.

Things we liked

  • Fluted interior design
  • Silicone nonstick coating for maximum release property
  • Made of aluminized steel
  • Free of BPA, PTFE, and PFOA
  • Lifetime warranty
  • 9-inch diameter
  • Easy to clean
  • Wrap resistant design

Things we did not like

  • Unlike most of the nonstick cake bake pans, this product comes with an invisible nonstick coating. Do not jump into conclusions before you use the product, the silicone coating along with fluted design offer superior nonstick features

5. Cuisinart 9-Inch Chef’s Classic Cake Pan

Cuisinart 9-Inch Chefs Classic Cake Pan

Buy From Amazon

Like the brand USA Pan, the brand Cuisinart is one of the top bakeware brands in the world today. This brand has its hands all over a different range of products, including cookware, kitchen appliances, and bakewares.

This cake bake pan comes made of heavy-gauge aluminized steel that has been designed in such a way that it can distribute the heat evenly all over its surface. This product comes with a nonstick coating on the interior and exterior that makes the product look attractive and at the same time offer maximum release feature to the product. One of the notable things about this product is that it comes with a thick rolled edges that can prevent the edges from wrapping at high temperature. This cake bake pan comes with a lifetime warranty on it and the manufacturer has designed the product in such a way that it can be a dishwasher.

Things we liked

  • Hard and extra rolled edges
  • Made of heavy-gauge aluminized steel
  • Anti wrapping design
  • Dishwasher safe product
  • Designed to spread heat evenly all over its surface
  • Lifetime warranty on the product
  • Durable nonstick coating on interior and exterior

Things we did not like

  • This product comes made of heavy-gauge aluminized steel and therefore, the pan is comparatively heavier than other pans

6. Aluminum Round Cake Pans

Aluminum Round Cake Pans

Buy From Amazon

Are you looking for a combo product that can satisfy your baking requirements? Then, Wilton aluminum round cake pan is the best option for you as it comes in a pack of 3 bake pans. Although the brand name Wilton might be unfamiliar to you, this brand in the past few years have gained positive reviews on their products.

This cake bake pan comes in a pack of three bake pans, a 4×2-inch pan, 6x2inch pan, and a 8×2-inch pan. Each type of pan comes designed with the same material, high-quality aluminum. The aluminum used is certified to be the best and it can spread the heat evenly all over its surface. Each pan is 2-inches deep and as the product is made of aluminum, it is not safe for dishwasher cleaning. However, the design is simple and therefore, manual cleaning is comparatively easier.One of the best things about this product is that it comes with a limited lifetime warranty.

Things we liked

  • Made of high-quality aluminum
  • Limited lifetime warranty on the product
  • Comes in a pack of 3
  • Durable and lightweight
  • Easy to clean
  • 2-inch depth

Things we did not like

  • Even though the manufacturer has mentioned the product made of aluminum, some customers reviewed the product to burn at very high temperature

7. Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Round Cake Pan

Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Round Cake Pan

Buy From Amazon

Chicago Metallic might be a new brand for you most of the people as it is not as famous as the other brands. This brand, however, this brand has been marketing top quality cake pans today.

This product comes designed in such a way that it can bake a triple-layered cake with ease. The product also can help the user prepare cinnamon rolls, brownies, etc. with ease. So, if you are looking for a multipurpose product, then this is it. You will be satisfied with this product. The entire product comes made of aluminized steel, which ensures superior heat conduction and even heat distribution over its surface. The nonstick coating on its surface is yet another important feature that makes the cake pan efficient. The manufacturer claims that this cake pan can handle up to 232-degree Celsius heat without wrapping or burning. One of the biggest advantages of this cake pan is that it comes with a lifetime limited warranty.

Things we liked

  • Durable and strong
  • Made of high-quality aluminized steel
  • Comes with a non-stick coating at both exterior and interior
  • Can be used to bake a triple-layered cake
  • Superior heat conduction feature
  • Easy to clean
  • Reinforced wire rod to prevent the pan from wrapping

Things we did not like

  • No such thing as of now

8. AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Round Baking Cake Pan

AmazonBasics Nonstick Carbon Steel Round Baking Cake Pan

Buy From Amazon

As the name itself suggests, this cake pan comes from the global brand AmazonBasics and it comes in a pack of two at a reasonable price and with exciting features.

Most of the people might assume that this brand lacks experience in manufacturing classic and good cake pans. However, based on our experience and our tests, let us reassure you that, this product does not lack quality. This cake pan comes made of high-quality carbon steel, which makes the product durable and spread heat evenly over its surface. One of the notable things about this product is that it comes with a nonstick coating on its surface that is guaranteed to last long without coming off under extreme circumstances. The manufacturer offers a limited 1-year warranty on this product. Yet another feature that this product offers is that it can handle up to 500-degree Fahrenheit without wrapping.

Things we liked

  • Made of heavy-duty carbon steel
  • Nonstick coating
  • Can handle up to 500-degree Fahrenheit
  • Best for 2-layer cakes
  • Comes in a pack of two
  • Reasonable price
  • Durable and even heat distributing
  • 1-year limited warranty

Things we did not like

  • Even though the manufacturer claims the nonstick is of superior quality, some customers reviewed the nonstick to come off after a few uses.

9. Tosnail 9″ Nonstick Round Cake Pan

Tosnail 9 Nonstick Round Cake Pan

Buy From Amazon

This cake bake pan comes in a pack of three and the price is reasonable when compared to other products on the list. It is not just the price that got this product a place on the list; the product offers equal features also.

This product comes made of durable carbon steel that is designed to offer maximum even heat distribution on its surface. One of the notable things about this product is that it comes with a smooth wire rod that prevents the pan from wrapping under high temperatures. Yet another important thing about this product is that it can be used for multiple purposes like baking pizza, pie, cinnamon rolls, etc. The pan also comes witha nonstick coating that ensures the cake will release after baking with ease.

Things we liked

  • Dishwasher safe
  • Made of durable carbon steel
  • Can be used for multiple cooking or baking need
  • Nonstick coating for easy release and cleaning
  • Smooth wire rod to prevent the pan from wrapping

Things we did not like

  • Nothing as such

10. Tebery 8-Inch Non-Stick Round Cake Pan

Tebery 8-Inch Non-Stick Round Cake Pan

Buy From Amazon

This cake bake pan comes in a pack of three and from the brand Tebery. This brand is new and it hasin recent months gained positive reviews on their products. This cake bake pan is one such top-rated product from this brand.

This product comes made of heavy-weight carbon steel that is durable and is designed in such a way that it can spread the heat evenly all over the material with ease. The product comes with a high-quality non-stick surface and this makes cleaning easy and release of cake simple. As mentioned above, this cake bake pan comes in a pack of three of different dimensions. Unlike most of the cake bake pans available on the market today, this product comes with side handles that make carrying this baking pan easy.

Things we liked

  • Comes in a pack of 3
  • Can handle up to 450-degree Fahrenheit
  • Made of carbon steel
  • Durable and designed to heat evenly
  • Top-notch rounded handles
  • Easy to clean
  • High-quality nonstick coating

Things we did not like

  • The manufacturer claims this product to be dishwasher safe, but it is not.

What To Consider When Buying The Round Cake Pan?

Like every cookware and bakeware available on the market today, a cake pan also comes made of different types of materials and made in various designs. There are also differentiated based on the features and the quality offered by the product. Here are some of the few top factors that you should consider while purchasing around cake pan today.

  • Based on material and design

There are different types of round cake pans available on the market today and each of them has different features that can offer more advantages or on the other hand, disadvantages.

  • Nonstick and nesting

This type of round cake pan is the most common and readily available cake pan available on the market today. You can find this cake pan in any supermarket near you, the design of this cake pan is unique. The sides of this cake pan are angled, and this, in turn, allows another pan to suit inside the other. This feature will help you frost the sides of the layer cake with ease, this is an advantage. However, let me point out a few of the disadvantages, this cake pan bakes a cake with thick brown crust at the bottom and darker band at the top. Some people have noticed this type of pan to sometimes result in a cake with gummy and dense raw dough at the middle.

  • Aluminized steel and straight-sided

Most of the people today have an issue with nonstick pans as the news about nonstick pan harmful for health started to come out. If you are one among such concerned customer, then, this type of cake pan is the best option for you. This type of cake pan comes made of thicker gauge steel which is coated with aluminum or silicon. This coating makes heat conduction slow; this, in turn, offers a natural taste to your cake. However, as mentioned in the beginning, this type of cake pan is comparatively expensive and less versatile. On the other hand, let me be frank if you have already used a non-stick pan then, this product might not satisfy you. But for first time users, this product is the best.

  • Anodized-aluminum and straight-sided

This type of cake pan is my favorite, yes, my favorite as anodized-aluminum is nonreactive material and, therefore, no issue of acidic taste or health issues. To my experience, this type of pan can bake a cake with nice a light bottom crust and it avoids wrinkling to a great extend. So much good features for a cake pan I would say.

  • Extra deep, anodized-aluminum, straight-sided

Not all people like their cake to be thin, some people like their cake to be thick and this cake pan is for such people. This pan is an ultra-deep and it can bake a cake with a thickness up to 8/3 inches. The straight and tall sides facilitate smooth and pale baking. This simply means your cake will have a delicate and thin top crust. This pan is best recommended for electric oven baking as they come with powerful top coils that heat the dough from the top. Apart from all these, deep pans are best for layered, as well as, molded desserts.

While the above-mentioned cake pan comes with a height of 8 inches, there is another type of pan that is 9-inch deep. However, let me warn you, using an 8-inch deep pan will be comparatively easier, but when it comes to 9-inch deep pans, most of the people assume, there is no difference. Let me let you, there is a lot of difference, even if it is just a 1-inch difference, if you do not fill in the right amount of dough, you will end up having a cake with good looking top, but under-cooked and uneven crust with numerous bubble space.Now, if you are a first time user, you should refer to a recipe that calls for the user of 9-inch cake pan. Remember, the amount of dough required for 8-inch and 9-inch pans is totally different.

  • Type of material

We have already seen above, different types of materials and design; however, it is not just limited to those materials mentioned above. You would be surprised to know that round cake pans can also found made of these materials also.

  • Aluminum:- Aluminum is one of the best conductors of heat and it is known the distribute heat evenly on its surface. This is why aluminum bakewares are common these days. However, aluminum cake pans are not designed for dishwasher cleaning. The user might find this a major drawback.
  • Stainless steel:- As you know, stainless steel is durable and dishwasher safe, probably one of the best materials that can last longer. However, if the oven, the temperature, and dough is not set accordingly, a stainless steel pan can result in baking your cake unevenly. Yes, stainless steel is not known to distribute heat evenly over its surface. But, if you go for aluminum and steel combination, then it would be perfect as they are much more efficient than steel pan or aluminum pans.
  • Silicone:- What? Silicone? Are you kidding me? No, silicone will not melt in the oven; however, if you are not careful while taking the silicone pan from the oven then you risk cracking or breaking the cake. On the other hand, cleaning silicone cake pans are easy and it is naturally nonstick.
  • Paper:- Yes, don’t be surprised; paper cake pans have been on the market for some time. Paper cake pans are designed in such a way that they can be used for a single-use. All you have to do is, bake your cake in the pan and then peel them off your cake and dispose of it. Paper cake pans are comparatively cheaper than all other cake pans.

Non-stick pans are not always the best:-

I personally know some people who are crazy about nonstick products, the same applies tobakewares also. But, let me warn you, nonstick products are not always the best. When it comes to cake pan, I don’t really think that a nonstick feature has much to offer in the process. If you prefer nonstick pan as it allows easy release of cake once baked, then, you can go for springform pans that are designed in such a way that you can remove the side of the pan to facilitate the easy release of the cake without cracking or breaking the crust. So, it would be best you avoid nonstick products and go for alternative models instead.

  • Price

We have noticed in recent times that some customers focus more on the price of the cake pan rather than the important factors like, size, material, and other features offered by the product. We recommend that you restrain yourselves from such trends; price of a product is important. However, you should know that you can analyze and decide for yourself if the price is reasonable or not based on the size, material, shape, and features the product offer. There is no guarantee that a premium-priced product will 100% better than cheaper models.

Now, if you are going for silicone or paper cake pans, the price will be comparatively low. When it comes to paper cake pans, they are the cheapest, but remember to check the quality of the paper and if the product is built to keep up with the market standards. The same applies to silicone pans, check the product specifications and make sure the silicone used is food grade and there are 100% guaranteed not to add any chemicals to the food cake or dough while baking.

  • Brand

Quality of the product and the commitment of manufacturing high-quality product is a key feature of a reputed brand. A reputed brand would never manufacture and market poor-quality products as it could destroy their credibility and reputation. This is why you must consider purchasing a cake pan from a reputed brand. If you are a beginner and if you have no idea of reputed cake pan brands, then here are a few top brands

  • Wilton
  • Cuisinart
  • Greenlife
  • Tosnail
  • Tebery
  • AmazonBasics

Apart from these brands, there are few other brands that market good quality cake pans today. However, it is not an easy task mentioning all the top brands here, but, we advise you that you consider purchasing a cake pan from a brand only after reading the customer reviews.

Final word

Baking a cake is an easy task if you find the right cake pan and if you can manage to mix the dough in the right proportion. Most of people assume that cake pan does not play an important role in baking a cake, however, they are wrong and they might not realize this fact until they have already bought a pan and tried using it. If you are serious about baking a cake and if you want the best, consider the factors mentioned in the buying guide and the products listed above the buying guide. Each and every product in the list is tested and certified to be the best and you will not regret purchasing any one of them.

Reply