10 Best Jelly Roll Pans 2020 – Expert Reviews & Guide

If you are a person who loves Jelly rolls, then you know the importance of jelly roll pans for preparing jelly rolls. For this rolled cakes, a perfect pan suited for the purpose is needed. If you want to eat jelly rolls and are preparing them at home for the first time, then you might think that a normal baking sheet serves the purpose. This is not correct as baking needs preciseness and perfect pans suited for the recipe. For these jelly rolls, you need to prepare thin cake sheets and then coat them with jelly or crème, which are then rolled into a cylinder shape. These make the perfect jelly rolls. Instead, if you use normal cake baking sheets, you will get an overcooked and undersized cake, which is not suitable for making a jelly roll. So, a perfect jelly roll pan helps you to make the perfect rolls.

The jelly roll pan looks like a cookie sheet and helps in making the cake sheets thin and strong, which is what precisely a jelly roll requires. You can also make cookies or roast some vegetables using the jelly roll pan. Like the baking pans, these jelly roll pans come in different materials and in different sizes. In this article, we are presenting a perfect list of best rated jelly roll pans for the money available in the market. You might want to look at each of these pans, the features and the things that we do/don’t like. These will help you decide on the perfect pan to purchase.

Along with that, we are also providing a buying guide to look at all the factors that you need to consider before deciding the product. We would suggest you to first go through the buying guide and then go through the list to find the best possible pan for your jelly roll recipe. Let us get started.

Best Buy Jelly Roll Pan Reviews

Jelly rolls are one of those recipes which require a perfect pan even though you have an extraordinary recipe at hand. The perfectness of the roll all depends on the pan that is used. Below, we are providing exactly the list that you want to look through to buy a jelly roll pan. We have done some research in selecting the list by considering the pan’s features, material, and ratings. Start looking at each of the pans, and when you come across the one that you liked the most, you can go ahead and click on the link that we have provided to purchase the pan online.

1. USA Pan Jelly Roll Baking Pan

USA Pan Jelly Roll Baking Pan

Buy From Amazon

One of the old popular brands for producing bakeware is the USA Pan brand. They have varied varieties of bakeware sets suitable for numerous baking activities. This particular set contains a jelly roll baking pan exclusively to make jelly rolls and a cooling rack, which is extremely useful. The pan is made of aluminized steel and is highly preferred by most of the professionals. The wavy surface on the pan gives it the extra nonstick properties and makes it warp-resistant.

Additionally, the pan’s surface is made of Americoat and special silicone coating giving it the perfect nonstick surface, and it is free from PTFE and PFOA. With this, you will get your baked goods from the pan quite easily, making it easy to clean as well. The pan dimensions measure 14.75 by 9.75 by 1 inch. The cooling rack measures 13.75 by 8.62 by 0.5 inches.

Things we liked

  • The pan is made of aluminized steel.
  • Contains the unique wavy surface allowing airflow for easy release and bake evenly
  • Silicone nonstick coating with americoat, and the pan is free from PTFE, BPA, and PFOA.
  • Ideal dimensions for making rolls.

Things we don’t like

  • Some people reviewed that the nonstick coating is thin, and it warps after a certain temperature.

2. KITCHENATICS Jelly Roll Cookie Pan Tray

KITCHENATICS Jelly Roll Cookie Pan Tray

Buy From Amazon

The bakeware from Kitchenatics has some unique features suitable for baking needs. Their jelly roll pan comes with a cooling rack too. This rack can be again used as a baking tool. You can place this rack inside the pan and cook some items in the oven, the pan helps to catch the drippings and the rack facilitates to bake the whole item evenly. The rack can be used for normal cooling purposes too. Cake or cookies and any baking item can be easily cooled on this rack. When it comes to material, the jelly roll pan is made of heavy-duty aluminum, and each wire rack is constructed using 304 stainless steel, which is rust free. Because of the heavy-duty material that the pan is built of, it is not easily warped under high temperatures. The pan is not only suitable for jelly rolls or cookies but also it can be used for cooking bacon, bake desserts, roast vegetables or make chicken wings. The rack is extremely useful to cook bacon or some roasted recipe. The pattern is a grid and is tightly made to ensure that the cooked items do not sag or fall. Also, the legs which are 1 inch each helps in even baking/cooking and also allows for proper cooling. The edges are perfectly rimmed helping for not dripping excess juices or oils from the food and also does not make the food toxic.

Things we liked

  • Comes as a combination pack of the cooling rack and the jelly roll pan
  • Available in many different sizes.
  • The pan is constructed with aluminum and the rack is made of stainless steel. They both are quite durable
  • The pan and rack can be used for multiple purposes
  • The tight grid pattern on the rack helps not to make the food soggy or fall

Things we don’t like

  • Some people felt that the nonstick material is not up to the mark and pan itself is not dishwasher safe

3. OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Jelly Roll

OXO Good Grips Non-Stick Pro Jelly Roll

Buy From Amazon

The next item from our list is also from a popular brand oxo. Their jelly roll pans have high-quality nonstick material and are of the two-layer coating. Also, the material has some ceramic touch to it making the pan much durable and long-lasting. The two layers have heavy-gauge aluminized steel material between them. This gives a perfect heat distribution, and it adds some extra strength to the pan as a whole.

On top of that, the pan is corrosion, stain, and abrasion-free. Also, the pan is free from toxic elements like PFOA. The edges are comfortable for a strong grip while you hold the pan to take it from the oven or put it into the oven. The sidewalls are straight and corners are crimp-free, making this pan very easy to clean. The surface has a micro-textured pattern giving rigidity to the pan allowing for the extra airflow which means an even baking. The surface is engraved with dimensions making it easy for you to identify the pan quickly. Speaking of the dimensions, this jelly roll pan’s inside dimensions measure 8.49 inches by 13.37 inches. The pan is designed, keeping in mind the main usage that is to make jelly rolls, bars or cookies. Vegetables can be roasted on this pan seamlessly.

Things we liked

  • The pan is made of 2 layers and has heavy-gauge aluminized steel promoting even heat distribution which helps not to burn the food.
  • The 2 layers, ceramic-reinforced material yields high-quality nonstick surface and it helps to protect the surface from stains, scratches, etc.,
  • The surface is having a micro-textured pattern providing sufficient airflow helping to bake the food evenly.
  • The edges are square rolled proving good grip to handle

Things we don’t like

  • Some people reviewed that the pan gets stains and gets warped after a few uses.
  • Not dishwasher safe

4. Doughmakers Jelly Roll Bake Pan

Doughmakers Jelly Roll Bake Pan

Buy From Amazon

With much-varied bakeware ranging from biscuit sheet till square cake pan, Doughmakers have become quite popular for their baking appliances. Their jelly roll pan is one among them. For any baking pan, the material of the pan decides the baking quality, and the outcome decides your efficiency. Likewise, this jelly roll pan is made of 18 gauge aluminum which most of the professionals prefer to use. The measurements of the pan are 15 by 10 by 0.75 inch making it quite good for making rolls. One other important thing about the baking pan is that the surface should be nonstick and should allow enough airflow to get the even baking of the food. When it comes to Doughmakers jelly roll pan, the surface is made of patented pebble pattern. This pattern is designed specially in Terre Haute, Indiana. This special pattern allows for enough airflow under the food that you place in the oven and prevents burning at uneven places. This means the baked good has even browning and as a result of the pattern, the baked goods easily slide off the pan. In addition to that, the pattern naturally allows for nonstick surface and you do not need to spray oil or butter on the surface additionally. This makes baked goods tasty as well as healthy. The pan itself is highly durable due to the material and does not form rust. Even if you happen to get any scratches on the pan, it does not affect the baking performance. Hand wash is suggestable for this pan.

Things we liked

  • The pan is made of high-quality material – 18 gauge aluminum
  • Patented special pebble pattern allows for natural nonstick surface and even baking
  • Highly durable and rust-free

Things we don’t like

  • Some people reviewed that the pan is getting discolored and oxidized after a few uses.

5. Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie

Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie

Buy From Amazon

The next jelly roll pan comes as a set with a cooling rack. The Chicago Metallic brand has been popular for its bakeware; this set of 2 helps to serve you with different uses. The jelly roll pan and the rack together can be used not only to make jelly rolls but also helps to bake cookies, one sheet recipes, bars, roast vegetables and even reheat any leftovers. With such multiple usages for this pan, no one can deny buying this set as it offers such wonderful features. When it comes to material, it is made of heavy-weight carbon steel which helps to distribute the heat evenly and also properly helps with weight. Both the jelly roll pan and cooling rack have nonstick material on the surface. This enables to release the baked goods easily and also helps for easy cleaning. The set comes with 2 pans, each measuring 17.75 by 13 by 1 inch. The rim is made of wire rod preventing any warping. The cooling rack which comes with this set of 2 pans measures 16.75 by 11.5 inches. One other thing about these baking sheets is that they can easily fit into any cupboard and can be stacked on other baking pans too. These pans can be conveniently washed using a dishwasher.

Things we liked

  • Multiple usages with the same pan
  • Comes as a set of 2 pans with a cooling rack
  • Made with high-quality material of carbon steel giving even heat distribution
  • Durable nonstick surface
  • Pans are of ideal size
  • Dishwasher safe

Things we don’t like

  • The material of the pan may not be as strong.

6. CHEFMADE Rimmed Baking Pan

CHEFMADE Rimmed Baking Pan

Buy From Amazon

The next baking pan from our list is for people who are looking for healthy and safe pans. These jelly roll pans are quite safe to use as they have food-grade silicone coating, FDA approved and does not release any harmful materials when baked at high temperatures. This usually happens with other pans. Also, the pan does not have Teflon. The material that this jelly pan is made of is 0.8 mm carbon steel which is of superior quality and provides even heat distribution. The edges are built strong which avoids warping and this ensures that the pan has long durability. In addition to that, the nonstick material on the surface ensures proper release of the baked goods and you do not need to use additional oil. Also, the baking takes quite less time, and hence the energy consumed is less saving you power and time. As the pan takes less time to bake, when it comes to family occasions or any gatherings, it saves a lot of time for you, helping you to spend less time in the kitchen and hence can enjoy with the family. Along with all these features, chefmade is offering service to refund or resolve a problem that you face with this pan. So, they provide excellent customer service.

Things we liked

  • Harsh chemicals or dangerous chemicals do not release from the pan and food remains safe
  • Made with high-quality carbon steel providing even heat distribution
  • The nonstick material is durable and provides easy release
  • Takes less time to bake and saves energy as well as time
  • Best customer service after-sale

Things we don’t like

  • Few customers felt that the material gets warped at high temperatures and also scratches form easily.

7. Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Jelly Roll Pan

Mrs. Andersons Baking Jelly Roll Pan

Buy From Amazon

Mrs. Anderson company has been providing some high-quality bakeware and they all proved to be perfect for home-style baking. The material of this jelly roll pan is made from 19-gauge aluminum which is heavyweight. The rim is reinforced beaded that does not tend to warp. The company claims that the pan, even when used a thousand times, will last. The pan can withstand temperature up to 480 degrees Fahrenheit. As it is made of heavyweight aluminum, heat is distributed evenly and is NSF approved. The surface is non-porous which means it eliminates any cross-contamination. The pan is safe for freezing and chilling food after use. This is an added advantage over other brand pans. The pan is rust-resistant, and when you just wipe off the pan with a damp sponge, the food cleans away. You can handwash the pan with mild soap but do not use any dishwasher. If you wish to pair this jelly roll baking pan with a baking mat, you can go with Mrs. Anderson’s baking mat.

Things we liked

  • Can use the jelly roll pan for multiple purposes like sweet recipes, cakes, cookies or even savory dishes
  • Made with 19-gauge aluminum material which is safe for high temperatures.
  • Prevents warping and distributes heat evenly.
  • Non-porous surface does not allow cross-contamination
  • Can be used to chill or freeze food

Things we don’t like

  • Not dishwasher safe

8. Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pan

Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pan

Buy From Amazon

With around 70 years of dedication and innovation in the family business, Nordic Ware is quite famous for its kitchen appliances. Among all the varied appliances that they offer, today we will be focusing on their jelly roll pan. The pan is extremely durable made with superior quality material. The pan is completely made of natural aluminum going through several procedures under supervision. The steel rims of the pan are also made at Nordic ware, which makes them all-natural and strong. The aluminum material facilitates even distribution of heat and is an added benefit due to its heavy weight. The surface of the pan is made of a prism grid, which is exclusive for the company. This helps for easy release of baked goods with good airflow and the pan stays longer. The pans measure 15.125 by 10.625 by 1 inch which is precise for making jelly rolls. They are available in 2 pack too.

Things we liked

  • The jelly roll pan is durable because of its prism grid
  • Even heat distribution due to the natural aluminum material
  • Ideal dimensions for making a jelly roll
  • Available as a double pack
  • Steel rim is exclusively made at Nordic Ware giving the maximum quality and rigidness

Things we don’t like

  • The pan might not be dishwasher safe.

9. Wilton Aluminum Jelly Roll and Cookie Pan

Wilton Aluminum Jelly Roll and Cookie Pan

Buy From Amazon

Wilton is one of the most popular brands for providing bakeware. They have almost all types of bakeware possible. The next item from our list is from Wilton and it is obviously a jelly roll pan. The most important aspect of any bakeware is that the baking should come out easily without getting stuck to the pan. This ensures the proper shape of the baking good and also helps to clean the pan easily. Wilton’s jelly roll pan is a nonstick pan that is scratch-resistant, and the food comes out easily without much effort. The bakeware is made of high-quality heavy gauge aluminum, which gives the highest durability and allows even distribution of heat. You can make jelly rolls and other baking recipes also on this jelly roll pan. When it comes to size, the pan measures around 10.5 by 15.5 inches. As an added bonus, you get a recipe with this wonderful jelly roll pan.

Things we liked

  • Multi-purpose pan
  • Ideal size for making jelly rolls
  • Comes with a recipe that you may use for your 1st experiment
  • The pan is made of heavy-gauge aluminum material providing high durability and allows for even distribution of heat
  • Nonstick surface which is scratch resistant and is easy to clean
  • Dishwasher safe

Things we don’t like

  • Some people mentioned that the pan might be thinner than expected
  • Cannot handle weighted baking goods
  • Some might have a problem with the quality

10. Luck Love Jelly Roll Pan

Luck Love Jelly Roll Pan

Buy From Amazon

The last jelly roll pan from our list is a bright pack of 2 pans. The pans are eco-friendly and are made of food-grade material – silicone. The silicone material gives flexibility to the pan and the durability is also high. The pan is BPA and FDA approved. This makes the pan completely healthy to use. Being made with silicone material, the food comes out of the pan quite easily due to its nonstick nature. So, it is quite easy to use and clean as well. Apart from using it as a baking mat for making pastries, cake or rolls, you can use them as a table mat or anti-hot pat. The mat is highly resistant to high and low temperatures. It can tolerate up to 230 degrees Celsius and can go as low as -40 degrees Celsius. The mat measures about 12.45 by 10.67 by 0.36 inches which is quite large enough for making rolls for a moderate family. As they are silicone mats, they weigh around 136 grams making them easy to carry. Also, you can easily store them as they occupy less space.

Things we liked

  • Made of nonstick food-grade silicone material
  • Comes as a pack of 2 with bright red colors
  • The mats can be used for baking as well as table mats
  • Can tolerate low as well as high temperatures
  • Ideal size

Things we don’t like

  • Some people find it hard to wash and say that after a few uses, the mat formed stains
  • The sides are too low to make a roll

How To Choose The Best Jolly Roll Pan

Before even selecting the best pan for your kitchen needs, you need to know what factors to look at while purchasing one of these wonderful pans. As we have provided the best list of pans for you, it might be difficult to select the one that best serves your purpose. In such cases, a buying guide is your best friend which allows you to make a decision. Below are the factors that you may want to consider before you select an ideal pan for your purpose.

  • Material

The material of the jelly roll pan is the first factor that you need to consider as it decides the result of your recipe. The higher is the quality of the pan, the best outcome you can get out of the pan. There are different types of materials that are used to make jelly roll pans – aluminum, stainless steel or non-stick pans. Based on the material, your jelly roll comes out perfect. All the materials have their own pros and cons. You need to decide which suits you more. Checking with professionals or chefs might help you a lot more than you can imagine. Also, check for reviews about the products and you will get to know the material durability and quality.

  • Dimension

The dimensions of the jelly roll pan are also pretty important to decide on the purchase. Most of the jelly roll pans come in small size, smaller than the half sheet pan. The usual sizes of the pan come in ½ or ¼ size. The dimensions of ½ sized jelly roll pan are 9 inches by 13 inches with a 1-inch depth. Whereas a ¼ sized jelly roll pan dimension is 12 inches by 17 inches with a depth of 1 inch. Based on your needs and size of your family, you can select from these two different dimension jelly roll pans.

  • Weight

As we have seen the different dimensions that these jelly pans are available in, it is also important to consider how heavy the pan is. If you are seeing a heavy pan, it has many advantages over the others. You can easily hold the pan in and out of the oven when it is heavy. It doesn’t tend to bend because of the batter and these pans are quite durable. Also, the heat distributes properly with these heavy and high-quality pans. To suit your needs, select the one from many available models in the market.

  • Edges

When it comes to selecting a jelly roll pan, many people often get confused with differentiating cookie sheets and jelly roll pans. Although you can make cookies in a jelly roll pan, you cannot make proper jelly rolls on cookie sheets. To differentiate between them, you need to carefully observe the edges of the pan that you are purchasing. A jelly roll pan usually has a 1-inch edge to make the thin cake sheets. On the other hand, a cookie sheet does not have this 1-inch edge and instead, the sheet is flat without having an edge. So, be careful while selecting the jelly roll pan as it is very easy to confuse it with a cookie sheet.

  • Purpose

When you decide to purchase a jelly roll pan, it is important to know the purpose of the pan before even deciding. This is because a wrong perception of the pan will only lead to a wastage of money or spoiling your recipe. The sole purpose of the jelly roll pan is that it is used to perfectly bake thin cake sheets, roast some vegetables like asparagus, or make rolls. So, if you would like to make something other than these, you will have to look for other baking pans. The same is applicable when you want to use a normal baking pan for making jelly rolls or other cake rolls. The purpose is not served. So, before you decide and purchase a jelly roll pan, make sure that you know its purpose.

Jelly Roll Pans Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the differences between the Jelly roll pans and a cookie sheet?

Jelly roll pans and a cookie sheet can both be used for the same purpose. However, the Jelly pans are a relatively simpler and more compact version of the baking pan. And as they are precisely made for the jellies and cookies, you can use them for baking the smaller proportions without worrying about the dishes to be under-cooked. The jelly pans are great for the smaller families, and if you are looking for better usability than the baking sheets or a cookie sheet, the jelly roll pans would be an excellent choice for you to make. Try your hands on them, and you are going to love their performance and easy usability.

2. What are the different aspects to look while purchasing a jelly roll pan?

As a popular kitchen tool, the jelly roll pans are also available in different sizes, designs, and from different brands. And this wide range in variety often confuses a buyer who is buying them for the first time. So, here are a few essential things that you should be looking for while purchasing a new jelly roll pan. Size of the pan, usability, and the thickness of the material. By keeping these three points in mind, you can easily choose the most efficient and reliable

3. What are the other uses of Jelly roll pans?

Jelly roll pans are perfect for baking. Whether you are making cookies, chips, or any other recipe that needs a flat bottom pan. With excellent performance and easy usability, the Jelly roll pans can be used for a variety of tasks. So, try your hands on them and explore the various uses of jelly roll pans.

4. What are the alternatives we can opt for?

Though the jelly roll pans are a great tool to have in the kitchen, the users often look for alternatives. Regardless of the reason for searching the other options, you can find a few tools that can be used in place of the jelly roll pans. And one of the most common and popularly used alternatives in the home kitchens is the baking sheet. The baking sheet acts similarly as the rolling pan, and as the jelly roll pans, it can also be used for several other tasks too. Though it is not as handy as the jelly roll pan, but if you do not have the jelly roll pans with you, you can make use of the baking sheets.

5. Are they worth buying?

Another important thing that comes to a buyer’s mind is whether the jelly roll pans are worth buying, or they should work with the alternatives. Well, this is all about preferences. Looking for the alternatives can’t completely replace the jelly roll pans. And there is no such real alternative of the jelly roll pans that provides the same level of usability and performance. So, if you have the budget and want to have a unique and useful pan at home, the jelly roll pans must be considered.

Final Verdict

When you are buying a jelly roll pan, you must remember that these sorts of purchases are a one-time investment and can be used any number of times in the future too. So, proper investment in the quality and size of the pan matters. You do not need to worry about the cake getting crumbled or spoiled with this pan. However, be sure to research the pan well before purchasing it. If you have any friends or relatives using the pan, you can ask them for reviews. Also, from the links that we have provided with our top 10 list, you can see the reviews from users yourself. The reviews will definitely be candid and you will get to know more about it from the people who used the pans themselves. Once you are satisfied with the product features and reviews, you can go ahead and purchase the one that perfectly suits you.